Sunday, March 7, 2010

You can't always get what you want...

Mill proposed that parents have an obligation to provide for their children if only so that the child views his or her life desirable (or, as I thought of it, livable) and nothing more, and then he exemplified the condition of the illegitimate child in order to represent the whole populace of children. In short, Mill concluded that children own little more than what their parents give them; however, this does sound as though it would propose a very unequal situation. For Mill continues on with a description of wealthy parents, who spare no expense for the upbringing of their children and who raise their children in an atmosphere of luxury and splendor. Those children will have money, things, and property handed to them with very little effort as compared to the children of modest or low-income families, who will, as Mill explained, only receive that which their parents can give to them. It would then be a fair assumption that the nature of property is solely dependent on education.

Comparing families of today, I think it's also fair to assume that our society is responsible for breeding feelings of insecurity and isolation among adolescents and young adults. The average family in America is middle- or modest-income but advertising makes us feel anything is attainable. Was Mill's proposition that all children should only have a claim to what their parents' can give them a healthy proposition? I can't help but think that our current situation has been leaving adolescents and young adults with a naive sense of the nature of property, fueling this condition of "living beyond one's means". Mill's argument, though a bitter pill to swallow, is also useful in preparing young minds for the hardships ahead.

2 comments:

  1. No doubt consumerism makes adolescence harder, more frustrating and confusing, than it might otherwise be. It is fair to say, however, that adolescence is pretty darn uncomfortable on its own account, and needs little help from this or that economic system.

    It is hard precisely because it is a transition from dependency to comparative independence, and I am inclined to agree with Mill that this experience is not helped by expectations of future inherited wealth. Parents owe children (their own and everyone else's) a great deal -- principally as rich an education of every sort as they can muster -- and afterward parents owe it to children to allow them to make their own way unhindered, either by desperate poverty or by unnecessary, demoralizing wealth.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i am not easily convinced adolescence has ever been easier or harder, only different from generation to generation. despite the challenges every child faces of becoming self sufficient it is the individual's obligation to happiness to rise above consumerism and other distractions that create the illusion of happiness. as much as i blame our society for much of the gratuitous suffering of our neighbors, insecurity is an option. there may be dispositions to insecurity like being born into a world we know nothing about, but there is no one to blame but the person who is experiencing the insecurity because they were not prepared and did not do the inner work to overcome. insecurity is the nudge (much in the same way pain is physically) to let us know something isn't right. our inclination when this happens is to hide it and forget it (out of sight out of mind) because our insecurity tells us to avoid confrontation (which is an insecurity in itself), but it is a cancer and it builds until is bursts out of their subconscious (perhaps when they are drunk). the only productive way to deal with insecurity is to confront it, identify the precise cause of the insecurity and to let it go. if you have learned what you needed to from the experience it wont have to resurface.

    ReplyDelete