Monday, February 22, 2010

Too many babies

Last week, I brought up the issue of parents having too many kids, which pertained to our discussion on rational purpose. I think it is irresponsible for people to have more than two kids of their own these days. For one, it is not fair to orphaned kids who desperately need a home. Second, having a couple of kids is natural; having more than ten is just stupid. Taking the case of the "octomom" scandal, which broke out last year, this is a perfect example of why we all need to understand that our actions have consequences. Indeed, Locke's allegory on the acorn comes to mind. (Similarly, I believe the "octomom" has more than what she can keep from rotting - but that's just being facetious.) Also Locke's perspective on children was that they were property because they are dependent on their parents for physical and mental support and therefore not mature enough to have property of their own. Thus, to tie in with our assumptions about rational purpose, I ask: would it be right to impose regulations on would-be parents so that they are restricted from having too many kids? If children are property, and we have an obligation to "enough and as good" with our property, shouldn't there be a maximum number of children allowed to be born to each couple? What implications would that have for our society and for the environment if we were not allowed to have as many babies?

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Conformity - what is it?

We somewhat touched on this idea the other day when discussing tacit consent. The notes that I was taking led me to the thought that consenting to one's government (or to be more specific, that which we create to establish positive law) might seem like a synonym for conformity. Conformity always seems to conjure images of communist China and people in gray jumper suits chanting "big brother".

I would like to argue that conformity is a good thing. It does not have to seem as frightening like it so often does. Tacit consent, as I understood it, enables us to identify with our culture and decide to have our culture protected by our government. For the most part, we (Americans) all enjoy conforming to our culture. We enjoy that which we have called our "freedoms" because it is convenient for us. And as we were talking about the other day, humans tend to follow the path of least resistance because it makes the most sense. It may sound like identity is compromised in favor of conveniences but I would also make the argument that identity is strengthened when we consent. Not for all people, of course.

The concern with conformity is that it affects identity but I feel as though identity does not reside in culture alone. We travel, we go to school, we have an adventure all outside the "confines" of our home, if we so choose - and these are values that are treasured just as much as getting married and having a family is treasured. Experience and the ability to gain experience is very much an individual thing - but how it is done should not be regulated by our government. In this way, conformity tends to hover on the line of helpful and frightening.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

A question

While in class the other day, I noted this question in my journal: what if there was another sentient - or intelligent - species on our planet? Hypothetically, if there had been two intelligent species that "evolved" at the same time, the human species being one of them, what would our perspective on life, liberty, and estate be? Would it be the same? Does it matter if there are two intelligent species versus one?

I'm not really sure how to go about answering this. I imagine that the intrinsic values we hold now would be very much the same, values such as "treat others as you wish to be treated' and "everyone has a right to exist". Two intelligent species would most likely coexist in this manner, given their capacity for reason and negotiation. However, that would be very much the idealist in me, hoping for the best. A more realistic - and probably more likely - scenario would be that given that two highly intelligent species existing at the same time would seek out similar resources on our planet, the existence of both would inevitably create an ecological as well as "evolutionary" disaster (I don't put much stock in Darwinian theories, but for the purposes of this example, it's there, in case anyone was wondering). But would it? I guess I'm going back and forth on this one.

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Property, Labor...and Billiards

Locke begins Chapter Five: Of Property by analyzing what property actually means. He said, "Though the earth, and all inferior creatures, be common to all men, yet every man has a property in his own person: this no body has any right to but himself. The labour of his body, and the work of his hands, we may say, are properly his" (II 19). There's this idea then that property has something more to do with the human body and how the human operates in his or her world. Suppose I wanted to play a round of pool. I would gather the balls, order them together in a triangle on the table, grab the cue stick, chalk the head of the cue stick, place the cue ball at the opposite end of the table, line up my shot and hit the cue, then that pretty little triangle of colorful balls bursts apart in all directions. Are those objects I talked about (the cue stick, the chalk, the balls) all my own property because I "labored" to pick them up and organize them? Locke asks where private property begins. Would I "own" the cue stick as soon as I used it to hit the balls, or sooner, such as when I picked it up? And does that ownership end the moment I put the cue stick down?

Considering billiards is not as drastic as hunting and gathering food, which was the example Locke had used, I still think the idea in itself is powerful: that I own myself (which includes all aspects, physical, emotional, and cognitive) and no one has any right to those aspects except me, that whatever I touch is mine, and whatever I produce from my labors is mine. Yet that is everyone's right, as Locke explains. We are all owners of our property in common. What if someone else wanted to play a round of pool at the same time I did? It would be reasonable to think that in this situation, we would agree to share ownership of the game and all its accessories. But what if it did not turn out to be a reasonable situation? What if, like children fighting over a single toy, this other person did not want to share this game with me? Who would be owner then?