Monday, February 22, 2010

Too many babies

Last week, I brought up the issue of parents having too many kids, which pertained to our discussion on rational purpose. I think it is irresponsible for people to have more than two kids of their own these days. For one, it is not fair to orphaned kids who desperately need a home. Second, having a couple of kids is natural; having more than ten is just stupid. Taking the case of the "octomom" scandal, which broke out last year, this is a perfect example of why we all need to understand that our actions have consequences. Indeed, Locke's allegory on the acorn comes to mind. (Similarly, I believe the "octomom" has more than what she can keep from rotting - but that's just being facetious.) Also Locke's perspective on children was that they were property because they are dependent on their parents for physical and mental support and therefore not mature enough to have property of their own. Thus, to tie in with our assumptions about rational purpose, I ask: would it be right to impose regulations on would-be parents so that they are restricted from having too many kids? If children are property, and we have an obligation to "enough and as good" with our property, shouldn't there be a maximum number of children allowed to be born to each couple? What implications would that have for our society and for the environment if we were not allowed to have as many babies?

5 comments:

  1. China has the "One Child Policy," and while this technically helps keep the population a more in check, it has caused a lot of problems.
    For example, many Chinese families prefer male children, and so there is a high rate of abortion, infanticide, neglect, and abandonment of female babies. There are some exceptions to the law, allowing couples who meet specific requirements to have more than one child, but they have to face other problems both legally and socially as a result.

    I think that having more children than you can handle is definitely a problem (in fact, it seems like it's trendy to have too many kids nowadays) but it would be tough for the government to pass and regulate a law restricting how many kids you could have.

    I think that the best way to go about it would be to let parents have as many kids as they want, as long as they can properly care for them. If they can't provide adequate care for the kids, then the government should first see if other family members can take care of them before ultimately removing them to a foster home or something.

    In order to regulate this, I think that families with, say, five or more children should have their living conditions inspected maybe once or twice a year, just to make sure that things aren't getting out of control. If the family passes the evaluation (including the family's income, the physical living conditions, making sure the kids are happy and comfortable), then they'd be fine. If not, the government could take the proper action.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I didn't think the original post was about state regulation at all; just a question of responsibility. If we look at this on the analogy of property acquisition, and well in advance of the question of regulation, it is fair to ask: how many children (if any) is it reasonable, and hence responsible, to have? The answer will differ, of course, in different times and places.

    Erica's proposal is that, under current conditions, two is the right number (though it adds nothing to the argument to say this is "natural"). But if the planet is already dangerously overpopulated, as it seems to be, how does reason warrant having any at all, or more than (say) an average of 1/10th of a child each for the next few generations until we get the climate stabilized?

    Once we figure out the right number, we can deliberate about rather different question of how to motivate people to abide by it (hint from Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum: educate and empower women and birth rates drop of themselves).

    ReplyDelete
  3. I remember from last semester's Environmental Ethics class that having a child was one of the most environmentally destructive things someone could do. I unfortunately don't remember who said this, but he/she suggested that someone could take 30 minute hot showers every day, drive a gas guzzler, eat factory farmed meat every day, etc., but not have a child, and still be less environmentally destructive than someone who was environmentally conscious but had a kid.

    I think that this argument ignores an important point, though: that environmentally-conscious parents are apt to have environmentally-conscious kids. If all of the environmentally-conscious people didn't have kids because they were too concerned for the environment, I would worry that the numbers of environmentally-conscious people in future generations would dwindle (kind of like that terrible, terrible movie "Idiocracy").

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes I saw that god-awful movie, too - even so, I think it made a good point, which is what you were saying - if fewer people raise children to be eco-conscious, there will be fewer eco-conscious people in the world. I don't think it would be as drastic as the movie of course but that movie also made me wonder about our urgent need to cut down on waste and find better ways to recycle.

    ReplyDelete
  5. limiting a family to having 1 child or perhaps 2 is asking a lot, it means giving up a habit that is both ingrained physiologically and socially within every person from before we were human. but i think it is appropriate since times are desperate and i cannot think of a more effective solution than to limit our procreation... we are quick to tell 3rd world countries to limit their birth rate, but as i mentioned in class american children use from 800-1000 times more energy than a child in a 3rd world country does.
    so i am willing to resist my urge of having 18 children like most nba players at the expense of having an eminent presence in one or two children (if only one, i promise to make sure they learn to share and not to spoil them, only child syndrome is not preferable or unavoidable)

    ReplyDelete