While in class the other day, I noted this question in my journal: what if there was another sentient - or intelligent - species on our planet? Hypothetically, if there had been two intelligent species that "evolved" at the same time, the human species being one of them, what would our perspective on life, liberty, and estate be? Would it be the same? Does it matter if there are two intelligent species versus one?
I'm not really sure how to go about answering this. I imagine that the intrinsic values we hold now would be very much the same, values such as "treat others as you wish to be treated' and "everyone has a right to exist". Two intelligent species would most likely coexist in this manner, given their capacity for reason and negotiation. However, that would be very much the idealist in me, hoping for the best. A more realistic - and probably more likely - scenario would be that given that two highly intelligent species existing at the same time would seek out similar resources on our planet, the existence of both would inevitably create an ecological as well as "evolutionary" disaster (I don't put much stock in Darwinian theories, but for the purposes of this example, it's there, in case anyone was wondering). But would it? I guess I'm going back and forth on this one.
Utilitarian Socialism
16 years ago

This may have happened, as the Cro Magnon and Neanderthal varieties of the genus Homo seem not to have interbred (so were probably different species), and may well have occupied adjacent territory in the same time period. We don't know much, unfortunately, about how they related, though there are suspicions that the Cro Magnon may have squeezed the Neanderthalers out.
ReplyDeleteBut how is the question any different from that of how people ought to behave toward those they merely (if falsely) believe to be different species, as has often been the case in human history?
It's like what you said about the opposing points of view between the Eurpoean settlers and the Native Americans. To "own" something was drastically different between the two cultures, but because one culture had guns, the other's perspective was rendered pointless.
ReplyDeleteIt might be a lame example, but I think it would probably be like it was in "Avatar"; we'd try to negotiate with the other species for resources when possible, and wage war with them if they didn't comply...the reverse might also be true.
ReplyDeleteThat's the way humans have (historically) dealt with unfamiliar people in unfamiliar cultures, so it seems reasonable to imagine that this behavior would hold true in regards to interacting with a separate intelligent species.