Sunday, January 31, 2010

Interpretive charity

I find that quite often interpretive charity is disabled in most public conversations. A most recent example of this is the American media, with regards to President Obama's first year. Many have started to call into question his abilities as a leader. This kind of reaction is irritable for many reasons, the main one being that our President is doing the kind of job not many people want to do nor are they qualified to do. This man is under so much pressure - and yet he has managed to improve our foreign relations, the international community is starting to see Americans in a less negative light, and issues such as health care, gay marriage, and the environment are at last being made top priorities in Washington. All of this while under the scrutiny of the press, the political pundits, and the American public on a daily basis.

But all of that aside, I can see why someone would find fault in a high-profile individual such as the American President. It is a right of ours as citizens to question the logic of our leaders. And it makes me wonder that interpretive charity may lose its value when the circumstances are just too critical or the number of people involved just too great. If this were just an issue of being involved in a one-on-one argument, then it would matter that both parties remain objective and try to stick to a higher, virtuous ground. In the case of my example, though, it begs me to ask: what becomes of intellectual virtue in extreme circumstances?