This is my revised mid-term essay. Personally, it's still a work-in-progress but I find the concept riveting. What do you think?
***
Intellectual property law protects an individual’s private (or concrete) idea from losing the right to that privacy in the state of common (or abstract) ideas. Common ideas are the thoughts we share and the verbal discussions we have with each other. Private ideas are the creations of the individual mind. The law protects private ideas because the individual has put a high value on his creation and seeks a profit (monetary or otherwise) from it. Private ideas require this protection to ensure their value is kept and not undermined by common, public uses of it. An idea in the commons suggests that there is no need for the law because it exists within the boundaries of natural rights. More than one person can share an idea about the weather and not trample on each other’s rights to belong to that idea. In other words, we can both agree that it is a nice day and not require a contract claiming that we each have exclusive rights to information expressed within that statement.
Libertarian philosophers disagree with IP law in its current state. They argue that the government’s involvement in the use of private information between individuals undermines the right to privacy (citation). Furthermore, IP law attacks individual identity because it enforces laws that protect people from “stealing” ideas from each other. However, I will examine the definition of IP and the objectives of its laws by using actual definitions from the World Intellectual Property Organization. Also, I will argue the Libertarian analysis by defining intellectual property in a way that both protects the individual’s right to his creations and the natural right of people to use ideas publicly.
Critics of IP law claim that the government abuses the rights of private ideas when it enforces laws to protect those rights. For instance, Roderick T. Long claims that the mere existence of IP law prevents the peaceful use of information between people. Additionally, one person cannot own the rights to information without owning other people. Here he argues that private ideas and common ideas are the same, which is why his claim that IP law does not protect the rights of all people seems to make sense. After all, as he explains, if someone writes a poem and his friend (call her Betty) memorizes that poem, she has made a “software duplicate” but the writer can’t claim any rights to that poem. Long insists that the writer remains a free and autonomous individual only when he does not make a claim of rights to the work he produced; yet Betty, who memorized the poem, can use her property (pens and paper) to make a “hard copy” and then Long argues that Betty’s hard copy is now hers to do whatever she want – so how is it not her property?
This almost sounds as though Long makes an argument for equality, provided that neither the writer nor Betty makes a claim to the poem as their individual property. However, Long’s perspective of a free-nation society without government intervention presents an unclear interpretation of IP ethics. In suggesting alternatives to IP rights, Long says, “If I profit from pirating your work, you have a legitimate moral claim against me, but that claim is not a right.” He presents a dilemma here: on the one hand, he argues that the poem belongs to both the writer and Betty as their property; however, on the other hand, he argues that the writer can make a moral claim against Betty for pirating his work – even though it was her property. Also, the writer can make a moral claim but not a rightful claim. According to Long, a rightful claim assumes government intervention, in which case, individual liberties are surrendered.
Long makes an incorrect assertion that copyright defenders claim the laws “protect only implementations of ideas, not the ideas themselves”. According to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), however, “property is not in those copies but in the information or knowledge reflected in them”. IP laws do protect original information and therefore guarantees the privatization of ideas. Long also argues that information is “not a concrete thing an individual can control”; however, WIPO states that a particular kind of information – a book, for example – is a concrete thing that an individual does own and the information contained within is protected by law. When under the law, it does not matter if the ideas in the book cause other ideas to occur in other people. What matters exclusively to the law is the rightful claim of ownership to the original idea.
However, only private ideas can be protected. According to WIPO, intellectual property “relates to items of information or knowledge, which can be incorporated in tangible objects…”. This definition separates private, profitable ideas from common, public ideas and turns private ideas into property while putting common ideas into a ‘non-property’ category. The mysterious transfer of ideas through the information contained within a document acts as property under the WIPO description, despite the abstract form it takes to exist. According to this assumption, material objects satisfy the criterion for law-based property because of their quantifiable nature.
Common ideas do not take the form of a tangible object because they cannot be easily quantified, yet they still exist. So, what are they? WIPO does not classify common ideas as property but what if WIPOs concept of property is limited to the concrete? In the abstract, ideas can be property, but even more so because of their inherent powerful force. Gifts, according to Marcel Mauss, possess a spirit, which acts as a force for an individual to pass on property to someone else. In this same sense, common ideas possess a hau, whereby in the aftermath of an original thought, an individual is compelled to share said thought with another. These ideas can be categorized by the taonga, or what Mauss describes as “…everything that makes one rich, powerful, and influential, and everything that can be exchanged, and used as an object for compensating others. These are exclusively the precious articles, talismans, emblems, mats, and sacred idols, sometimes even the traditions, cults, and magic rituals” (10). The taonga represent a value system of property, to the extent that taonga exchanged between people carry the hau of people, or in Mauss’s words: “…the taonga are strongly linked to the person, the clan, and the earth, at least in the theory of Maori law and religion. They are the vehicle for its mana, its magical, religious, and spiritual force” (10). Common ideas in the form of taonga, then, act as the vehicle, or “mana” for the exchange of ideas. Take for instance a group discussion. Ideas exchange between arguing parties and the force of momentum, the hau, or the spirit of information maintains within the debate; thus the nature of communication continues. Also notice that in group discussions, no one needs to make a claim to their idea. Property in this condition is communal and the sharing of common ideas is a sign of the group’s need for this social exchange.
Common ideas are not inactive. Reciprocation, therefore, acts as the will of the gift-receiver to keep the hau going. In Mauss’s words, “This is because the taonga is animated by the hau of its forest, its native health and soil. It is truly ‘native’: the hau follows after anyone possessing the thing” (12). How we think, how we move, how we speak all depend on our social abilities. Gift-giving then is as much of a process of education, of learning as it is a powerful connector within the group. Common ideas, being at the core of our ability to reason and to be motivated to socialize, are gifts in this form.
While we place an intrinsic value on common ideas, we place an economic value on an idea when we want to turn it into our private property. The right to the creations of one’s own mind must be protected by law, particularly since it is in human nature to seek ways to profit from an idea. Based on this principle, the law acts not only as a protector of an individual’s claim to an idea but also that individual’s right to profit off of it. WIPO states that countries establish IP law in order to, “…give statutory expression to the moral and economic rights of creators in their creations”. Thus, individuals have an inherent right to the economic value that their ideas produce. Also, an objective of IP law is to “encourage fair trade, which would contribute to economic and social development”. In effect, WIPO claims that fair, economic trading of property, including intellectual property, is supposed to act as a foundation for both economic and social development.
IP laws are critical in retaining the intrinsic value of common ideas. While Long makes assertions that IP laws inhibit identity, it is still a right – and a protected one at that – for individuals to choose whether or not to profit from their ideas. In Long’s hypothetical situation where IP laws are severely limited, he assumes that people naturally defend each other’s intellectual property rights while at the same time arguing that people have no rights to claim their property because it is just a “given”. I think that his assumption may be due in part to his other assumption that common ideas and private ideas are one in the same. Perhaps he does not assume that people naturally tend to believe it is right to make a claim on an idea. After all, what person wouldn’t claim a right to intellectual property if, for instance, that person had discovered a cure for cancer? According to Long’s hypothetical situation, that person could not make a claim to his own discovery, even though he rightfully deserved compensation for the labor he put in to making that discovery. This is why intellectual property must be properly defined. WIPO makes an attempt but they do not include what intellectual property is not, and to that end, I submit that common ideas belong to the community as air or water belongs to the community, while private ideas belong to individuals who make a rightful claim of ownership.
Utilitarian Socialism
16 years ago
