Sunday, March 28, 2010

Essay

(For whatever reason, I cannot find the finalized draft but what I'm posting here is the closest to what I handed in to class. As soon as I have my other draft returned to me, I will post it as an edit on this post.)



Brainstorm: the Ownership of Ideas

Do we own our thoughts? Are thoughts and ideas property? Property in a hypothetical sense can be defined as that which one claims belongs to her person and is therefore a definitive piece of her identity. An original idea belongs to one in a sense – but is it one’s property? Property can be lost, stolen, sold, or trashed. An idea can do all these as well in the sense that the exchange of an idea from one’s thoughts to another person’s thoughts can be exposed to elements of commercialization. One can “sell” her idea – if it is a good one – to someone interested in profiting from it. She can have her idea legally “stolen” by someone who takes her idea and patents it or plagiarizes it without her permission. However, unlike tangible property, ideas remain intact throughout the process of exchange. Thus ideas are property – but even more so because ideas have the advantage of being intangible and infinite.

In an education setting, ideas are swapped frequently, almost recklessly between students and professors on a daily basis. Ideas in schools, like those found in required summer readings or discussed in biology labs, are primarily for knowledge purposes. At this stage, ideas ascend the connection to property. Tangible items do not conjure the chills of fear or pleasure that come from a novel idea. A fifteen-year-old reading 1984 for the first time might never view society the same way again. She might have believed that her home was safe and that it was free, but now after George Orwell painted a different picture of society she realizes that she knows very little about what it means to truly be free, having never experienced anything like conformity or identity loss as described in the story. Also, she may realize that even if this kind of dystopia never occurs during her lifetime, the very idea of it occurring makes it a possibility, for if Orwell thought of it half a century ago, what stops other people from having similar ideas, especially the kind of people who are in a position of power to act on those ideas? This is a significant issue then because it is unclear how to hold professors or students responsible for the kinds of thoughts they will inevitably have. Reading 1984 for example may not frighten everybody as it does the fifteen-year-old. In fact, the ideas expressed in the writing could lead another student to have ideas about how to prevent authoritarianism, or another student could have ideas about self-reliance. What is critical here, though, is that ideas are more than just something that we own. The process of having an idea and then of exchanging said idea with a person or multiple persons is how we educate and by educate grow or respond cognitively to the causes and effects of our environment.

The response to idea exchange in the classroom then is just as significant as the process of exchange itself. In 1925, John T. Stopes was put on trial for teaching evolution in a Tennessee classroom. Eight decades later, in mid-2005, Kansas education authorities argued in court that Darwinian evolution contained holes, such as the formation of DNA that could only be explained by some form of intelligent design. Controversy on the subject of evolution continues in America to this day, despite the benefits the subject yields. While it is known that Darwinian evolution is only a theory and that it does in fact contain many inexplicable areas, wanting to ban it from the curriculum altogether is simply unjust. Banning the study of another’s ideas is equivalent to banning the state of ideas. Having thoughts of one’s own is meaningless if it is not challenged by the thoughts of others, particularly if those ideas were acted upon or studied in a scholarly manner. Aside from the flaws in his theory, Charles Darwin did in fact spend quite a long time making detailed observations of the creatures he saw on the Canary Islands. His ideas sprouted from natural fact. The theory that resulted was made public specifically for the purpose of educating others about what he found because it was revolutionary and deserved public attention. Educational censorship is simply not education. The process of education functions as a marketplace for gaining and owning ideas. Those who run the schools and teach in the classrooms have a moral obligation to ensure that the exchange of ideas is not only practiced but that it is practiced well and with clarity.

Education is a random process but through all the chaos of thought exchanges every student has the opportunity to receive something greater than any tangible object. In this way, ideas are more than property – they are gifts. The teacher gives ideas through lecture and literature, the student receives what he can understand and attempts to reciprocate through passing in homework assignments and performing well on exams. We are receptive to gifts, more so than the general acquisition of things. This could be due to our openness to be given something new or meaningful that allows us to grow. Thus giving an idea is more like giving a gift of enlightenment. “If one gives things and returns them, it is because one is giving and returning ‘respects’ – we still say ‘courtesies’. Yet it is also because by giving one is giving oneself, and if one gives oneself, it is because one ‘owes’ oneself – one’s person and one’s goods – to others” (Mauss p. 46).

On the other hand, teachers that are not giving and students that are not receptive make the process of idea-giving stillborn. If a teacher cannot get the books or DVDs he wants to present to his students because the state cut back on spending in schools, that teacher will find the process of idea-giving i.e. doing his job has become stale. For one thing, he feels his students are expecting him to provide them with resources that they wouldn’t ordinarily come across on their own. Disappointment does a lot to curb enthusiasm for teaching. If a student goes into the classroom already determined to hate the subject, there’s nothing the teacher could do to make her learn. Therefore, for each party to successfully exchange ideas, each party is obligated to have motivation. If school was thought more of a gift than an institution, motivation may not be so hard to come by.

Motivation is not something everyone is born with and many people can go a lifetime without having any enthusiasm for anything. The Greeks believed that the ultimate sin was to waste your life away, especially when you have potential in the capacity for thinking. But why ought I be motivated to exchange ideas? It is not necessary for any one person to be motivated. Of course, motivation or will power of some kind is necessary for the survival of the species – but any random individual does not have to subscribe to the Greek way of thinking. Thus the question remains: without any religious principles clouding judgment, for what secular reason ought I have motivation to take part in the exchange of ideas? I don’t have to go to school but why ought I? This could have more to do with the spirit of gift-giving, in that my individualism is akin to my spirit and when I exchange ideas, I am simultaneously giving up or separating that identity from myself as well as retaining that piece of myself so that the person I am exchanging with knows me and I am still here. Idea-giving is at once selfish and selfless, striking a moderate balance between what I know and what I share as well as what I learn and what I reciprocate.



(Again, apologies for this draft's "incompleteness". Even the draft handed in to class was not my best work but I hope that by getting your feedback and with more research I can polish it up into something far more readable.)

No comments:

Post a Comment