In class today, we tried to come to an understanding about what Bentham said about equality and property. We seemed to just barely graze the tip of the iceberg, so to speak, so I wanted to continue here with a discussion on his notion of a "portion of wealth". A "portion" of wealth may refer to some predetermined division of property among individuals, if we assume that Bentham was talking about this portion being fairly equal from one person to the next. I wonder, though, could a "portion of wealth" also refer to the division of property between classes, such that those with far more property would have a larger portion of a collective wealth and the lower classes would have a lower portion? In other words, if I have accumulated and own more property than my neighbor, would I own a bigger portion of the benefits that come with it, such as in the case of owning stock in a company?
On a final note, Bentham corrected himself when he said, "I have said that for each portion of wealth there is a corresponding portion of happiness. To speak more exactly, it ought rather to be said, a certain chance of happiness" (Macpherson, p. 47). What did he mean by a "certain chance" and why not say a "portion" of happiness?
Utilitarian Socialism
16 years ago

I understand this to mean that the accumulation of wealth does not in itself guarantee happiness. So, wealth in this sense is not a necessary condition for happiness. Bentham states that the term wealth “embraces everything which serves as either subsistence or abundance”. He also posits that it is “the pleasure of acquisition, not the satisfaction of possessing, which gives the greatest delights”. If we interpret this to mean ‘passion’ then it makes sense that happiness can indeed flourish in a person that does not possess what we might consider traditional wealth. Also, I think people with an abundance of goodwill, passion, and genuine happiness, are wealthy people.
ReplyDeleteKeane I think your right however it seems that what we were getting at in class is that its not just this 'passion' element that gives one happiness but in fact actual wealth to a certain extent. I think the example was put forth of the person that does not have food and the one does, which one is happier? however I do it that after a certain extent it is the acquisition of the object of the things that makes the person believe they are happier but it seems that what Bentham is getting at is that this only occurs after there been an unequal divide in wealth, which makes the individual at the lower end of that pole feel that he is missing out.
ReplyDeleteAs far as the "portion of wealth" segment of this blog was concerned, I believe that Bentham was suggesting a direct correlation between wealth and happiness (which he later refines with his threshhold proviso). For every potrion (unit) of wealth, one is afforded a portion (unit) of happniess, indicating a positive correlation.
ReplyDeleteI think that Bentham edited his previously made statements from "portion" of happiness to a "certain chance" of happiness because he must concede that even he can't claim that more wealth will absolutely result in more happniess. He claims that happiness is affected by a variety of facotrs beyond wealth.
I am still curious about the nature of benefits though. Bentham suggested that a portion of wealth correlates to a portion of happiness (at least that's the assumption). What I am suggesting is that there are obvious benefits to owning more than your neighbor, and it may be that owning more correlates to knowing more or being more. Is happiness from knowledge limited in the same way happiness from money or things is limited?
ReplyDelete