Sunday, April 11, 2010

Lately, I've wondered about the "pureness" of gift-giving. It makes me think back to when I struggled to see how altruism was real. Is there such a thing as pure altruism? Is there such a thing as a gift given out of pure benevolence?

I've always found it difficult to not find some ulterior motive of the person committing the act of altruism. I read a story about a police officer who happened to be passing by a person about to jump off a bridge. The officer bolted from his car and grabbed the person just in the nick of time, nearly falling off the bridge in the process. Later, when he had been interviewed, he said that he was only thinking about the guilt he would have felt had he let the person jump. The officer's act of bravery - or stupidity, however you look at it - saved the life of another person's nearly at the cost of his own life. At first glance, it would seem that the officer was putting the person in danger ahead of himself. But what he said was significant: he would have felt guilty. To me, that doesn't exactly sound like someone purely being benevolent. That sounds like someone trying to cover his own behind.

With gifts, is it the same? The other day, I sent a card to a friend I haven't spoken to in awhile. Now, I could claim that I was just doing it out of the kindness of my heart but deep, deep down I knew that the only reason why I did it was purely for the attention I would receive in return. This makes me wonder if our concept of gifts and altruism is pure naivete or wishful thinking.

2 comments:

  1. I suspect a certain species of reductive Hobbesian thinking has wormed its way into our brains, forcing us to rehash this false dilemma eternally.

    I seriously doubt there ever was a human motivation that was wholly pure. This does not, however, call into question the possibility of either altruism or gift-giving as genuine intentions. Just as these are generally mixed with some self-regard, so even egregiously selfish motives are likewise generally mixed with consideration for others. This complexity is just an inescapable consequence of our social nature.

    ReplyDelete
  2. i would neglect altruism, or purity if there was no joy in giving the gift. i find it necessary to differentiate a selfish act (done to benefit you materialistically which is an attempt to satisfy the ego) and one done that the side effect of giving the gift makes you feel good about having enough of something to give without it hurting you. the win-win situation is the only option worth pursuing. a sacrifice is a situation where you give up more of yourself than was worth, in which case the gift should be denied at an available expense.

    ReplyDelete