Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Property, Labor...and Billiards

Locke begins Chapter Five: Of Property by analyzing what property actually means. He said, "Though the earth, and all inferior creatures, be common to all men, yet every man has a property in his own person: this no body has any right to but himself. The labour of his body, and the work of his hands, we may say, are properly his" (II 19). There's this idea then that property has something more to do with the human body and how the human operates in his or her world. Suppose I wanted to play a round of pool. I would gather the balls, order them together in a triangle on the table, grab the cue stick, chalk the head of the cue stick, place the cue ball at the opposite end of the table, line up my shot and hit the cue, then that pretty little triangle of colorful balls bursts apart in all directions. Are those objects I talked about (the cue stick, the chalk, the balls) all my own property because I "labored" to pick them up and organize them? Locke asks where private property begins. Would I "own" the cue stick as soon as I used it to hit the balls, or sooner, such as when I picked it up? And does that ownership end the moment I put the cue stick down?

Considering billiards is not as drastic as hunting and gathering food, which was the example Locke had used, I still think the idea in itself is powerful: that I own myself (which includes all aspects, physical, emotional, and cognitive) and no one has any right to those aspects except me, that whatever I touch is mine, and whatever I produce from my labors is mine. Yet that is everyone's right, as Locke explains. We are all owners of our property in common. What if someone else wanted to play a round of pool at the same time I did? It would be reasonable to think that in this situation, we would agree to share ownership of the game and all its accessories. But what if it did not turn out to be a reasonable situation? What if, like children fighting over a single toy, this other person did not want to share this game with me? Who would be owner then?

5 comments:

  1. I guess it depends on who actually owns the billiards stuff; if the table and balls were bought with your own money, or made by you, and you claimed ownership of them, then theoretically you'd have the right to deny other people the right to use them. If they belonged to the owner of whatever establishment they were in, then they wouldn't really count as "yours" because you "labored" to set the game up. In this case, you would not have the right to exclude others from using it; that right would rest with whomever actually paid for the pool table to put in their bowling alley or bar or whatever.

    Similarly, say I was at an auction with a display of expensive jewelry. Someone knocks the display over, and I alone, acting out of good will, pick up all the jewelry and arrange it as it was originally. This doesn't make it mine because I "labored" on it; the people who either labored to physically make the jewelry, or who physically labored to earn money to buy the jewelry, have the higher right of ownership.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Remember that this iconic description of ownership by simple appropriation is predicated on everything being in its natural, common state (the state of nature). Though the principles are the same, matters are rather different where industrial artifacts like pool cues, etc. are concerned.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The pool stick, the pool table and everything else either belong to you or somebody else. The rights of ownership, in this case, do not take place in a state of nature. Instead, the context is one that has laws which prevent the absurdity that would ensue if we perceived everything in a state of nature.
    On the other hand, the act of playing pool calls for an amount of labor to exert (metaphorically speaking). The labor put forth will, in turn, give you more experience and knowledge of the game. The latter yield can be seen as the fruits of your labor.
    In the instance of all the materials not belonging to you, the fruits of your labor will still probably be the same. Essentially, the owner is offering his/her property for others to enjoy (i.e. the common good). In this sense, the state of nature is being represented. Nevertheless, using his/her property does not automatically make it yours and I'm sure Locke would agree.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This makes me think of how we get this idea of temporary ownership. I'm currently sitting in the library, at a desk. This is my favorite desk because it faces the quad and the sun shines in and keeps me warm. I sit here every time I come to the library...unless it's already occupied. When I come in and someone's already sitting here, I always think, "ugh, that's my desk!" I suppose we can feel possessive over things that we know aren't really ours.

    Still, if I was sitting here at this desk with all of my stuff on it, got up to get a book, and came back to find someone else sitting here, I think I'd have grounds to politely ask them to get up, even though this desk technically doesn't belong to me.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A useful distinction, Shelby, between an emotional sense of possessiveness and objective entitlement. It's worth considering, however, whether Locke's idea that we are entitled to the product of our labor (in appropriate circumstances) doesn't get a fair bit of its intuitive plausibility from just that feeling we tend to have when we invest ourselves in creating something (even just creating a comfortable spot in the moment!).

    As we will see presently, Marx's notion of alienation -- that a worker is diminished when some of the surplus value she creates is appropriated as profits for others -- rests on a very similar presupposition.

    ReplyDelete