Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Conformity - what is it?

We somewhat touched on this idea the other day when discussing tacit consent. The notes that I was taking led me to the thought that consenting to one's government (or to be more specific, that which we create to establish positive law) might seem like a synonym for conformity. Conformity always seems to conjure images of communist China and people in gray jumper suits chanting "big brother".

I would like to argue that conformity is a good thing. It does not have to seem as frightening like it so often does. Tacit consent, as I understood it, enables us to identify with our culture and decide to have our culture protected by our government. For the most part, we (Americans) all enjoy conforming to our culture. We enjoy that which we have called our "freedoms" because it is convenient for us. And as we were talking about the other day, humans tend to follow the path of least resistance because it makes the most sense. It may sound like identity is compromised in favor of conveniences but I would also make the argument that identity is strengthened when we consent. Not for all people, of course.

The concern with conformity is that it affects identity but I feel as though identity does not reside in culture alone. We travel, we go to school, we have an adventure all outside the "confines" of our home, if we so choose - and these are values that are treasured just as much as getting married and having a family is treasured. Experience and the ability to gain experience is very much an individual thing - but how it is done should not be regulated by our government. In this way, conformity tends to hover on the line of helpful and frightening.

2 comments:

  1. Nietzsche makes a helpful distinction between what he calls free spirits and bound spirits, arguing that every society needs both those who push its boundaries and those who preserve its institutions if it is to remain vital. In this light, conformity is neither a good nor a bad thing, but a necessary thing that must be kept in dynamic equilibrium with its opposite.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Agreed with the above. I don't think the subject of conformity on its own terms is strictly destructive or beneficial--it largely boils down to its context.

    We all conform to some vague extent, and in that sense, it's a helpful practice. It allows us to associate with our family, friends and culture, forming out own identity and idiosyncrasies in the process, but still keeping true to that which formed us. I think the idea of equilibrium is key component... to little conforming can bring about a lack of coherence and communicative chaos, whereas too much conformity brings stagnation and destruction. Moderation, as with all things, is probably the ideal.

    ReplyDelete